I've found that singers generally have three methods of support -- "in and up," "down and out," or "appoggio" as defined by Dr. Hanson (since, like "bel canto," most teachers call their method appoggio, whatever it happens to be).
It seems to me, just from talking to people and reading, that more women use "in and up" and more men use "down and out," and that the appoggio technique is spread evenly across the board. I have heard fabulous singers who do all three -- some started out with appoggio but found it too "still," or found the inhalation feeling carried too much tension, and improved tremendously by applying abdominal support one way or another. Some get into the habit of abusing the first two ways in rigorous, punchy ways, and so find freedom when they switch to the appoggio.
How to define them? From my own experience and experimentation, I feel like "in and up" involves pulling the lower abs in, then breathing down low and expanding the ribs and back out in all directions, then singing -- keeping the abs firm and pulled in (almost like you're wringing a towel) and (this is the hard part) keeping the ribs expanded as you sing. I feel like "down and out" is when you breath deeply (relaxed), belly expands with breath, and then you feel a steady push outward of the lower abs as you sing. I feel like the appoggio method is about taking a moderately-full breath, then concentrating on the stillness of the position (not moving the muscles either in or out), and feeling like you're sucking the air back in, as you sing. It does feel remarkably like a soft, moist breath.
I personally, at this stage in my development, find the appoggio method works best in my middle range, and the "in and up" method gives me the needed breath pressure in forte top notes.
Maybe as I develop more, I will switch around. But good singers use all three approaches (and I'm sure there are combinations and other ideas), so I wouldn't say that one is definitive and the others will serve you less.
Isabelle B.
===== Isabelle Bracamonte San Francisco, CA ibracamonte@y...
__________________________________________________
|