Vocalist.org archive


From:  "Caio Rossi" <caioross@z...>
Date:  Fri Apr 14, 2000  11:13 am
Subject:  Re: [vocalist-temporary] Pavarotti.


Mirko wrote:


>Caio wrote after sending a bad review of Pavarotti-
>
>>Moral: if he can, why can't we? :-)
>
>I really hope you were ":-)" when you sent this review, caio.
>
>If you have done as much for opera as Pav has, then you can have a bad
night
>too and be excused. He's coming to the end of his career as he is 63+, so
>give him a break!!! Why do you post negative reviews of Pav? What does
>that serve? Watching the rise and fall of something beautiful?? Do we HAVE
>to be reminded??? Does it serve you personally? Caio, I know you probably
>were only kidding. but honestly, why write it?
>
>Remember, all singers have bad nights now and then, especially at over 60.
>Be nice! By the way, when I saw him in Brisbane at the end of last year,
he
>was incredible (even though the moron next to me decided that the highlight
>of 'vesta la giubba' should be a good place to start opening up a noisy bag
>of chips. Let me tell you, I almost committed a capital offence).
>
>this goes to anyone- If you flame the great singers, I will flame you
>greatly. :-)


Mirko, all I can say is: relax and have fun! Concerning Pavarotti, ALL THE
TIMES he came to Brazil, I think they were 3 or 4 times, he had bad reviews.
At a stadium here is SP he did so badly, some 6 years ago, that people
seemed to prefer the singers in the audience who decided to show their
abilities during the breaks. When I posted it, I wanted to make 3 points:
why to blame Church for not having great technique and charging 150 for her
presentations, while he has the whole industry backing him up, and pop stars
and everything, and gives concerts to help poor people around the world that
serve as merchandising for them all and don't solve any problems at all;
why do people, mostly on the list, criticize pop singers so often while
opera singers do also have their bad nights, bad repeated nights, bad over
and over again nights...;
and, finally, try to show that we ourselves can develop our technique and
not necessarily reach perfection all the time, or ever.

Regarding what you said about him having been great in the past, it doesn't
justify his bad performance now. If you're charging a lot of money from
people because you know they think you're great, and you know you're not
anymore, it's imoral. And all the money he raises with his presentations to
'help poor people' is compensated by his terrible presentations charging
thousands of dollars from the municipality of an underdeveloped and poor
city like San Salvador. He may not be a great singer anymore, but he's still
a great businessman!

Best regards,

Caio Rossi



emusic.com