I really must agree with Alleson about the benefits of performing during your singing education. My (now ex-)teacher offers her students a lot of possibilities to perform on student concerts in the protected environment of our school. Singing on a stage is so different from singing in a small classroom with only your teacher to watch you. I know a lot of people who can sing everything in that intimate situation but once they are on stage they loose everything. And I know others who suddenly sing a lot better than they could in their lessons. Most of the students have to learn how to perform, how to handle the nerves, what to do with their body – for instance with their arms – on a stage. And I think you really have to start very soon with that so you can build it up gradually. I know students who never sang one concert before their examination and then they were disappointed that they lost so much on that examination! I find it also easier to keep focused on your study when you know you have a concert coming. You can build up to it. And of course you learn so much by listening to the performances of the other students! Not only you learn to see the things they do good but – even more important – you learn also by their mistakes! And suddenly you believe more what your teachers says because you see and hear what she means! One of the most important things of an education is to learn to hear what is good and what is wrong because when you are just starting you haven’t got an idea of that. And of course hearing a more advanced student can be very motivating to study yourself!
I don’t think you can learn how to sing only by singing arias. I think both aria and lied should be in a good balance in an education. And that balance has to be achieved very individually, each voice and each singer is different. Out of my own experience I can say that in my first year I was really reluctantly about singing pianissimo because I couldn’t manage it technically. So in my voice lessons I never had to sing piano from my teacher. She wanted it technically correct. But in my chamber music lessons, where they interpretation is more important than the technique, they really stimulated me to try it. And I’m very glad they did. Ok, at first I cheated on my technique but it was only by trying it that I mastered it and that my fear of singing piano went away. As you can learn a lot with technical exercises, you can also by trying and failing, and trying it again!
So speaking for myself, I learned an awful lot with performing and with singing both arias and lieder! Balance is everything in life!
Greetings, Annelies
________________________________________________________________________
|