Shannon,
I think it is great that you have a kid who loves to sing. There are some concerns, in my mind about huge ranges in songs for little ones (even 11 year olds). I think that its not too surprising when younger people can sing higher notes with ease, since their vocal folds are not completely mature, but the caution has to be that there will be changes. As her voice matures, she may find it necessary to make adjustments in order to sing the same literature, or to make the same sounds. In my mind, this is where the danger lies. Right now, she may be singing very free, but as her body changes (as it may already be doing), there will be vocal changes as well. I think I would discourage her from singing (too) difficult literature for now, focusing instead on other musical skills (piano, theory, even music history) that will serve her well when her voice is mature. Of course, don't keep her from singing, but I would be firm about what literature she should and should not sing. And if you feel the teacher is abusing her in any way, get a different teacher.
Now, let me say that I am no expert on children's voices, but I am (as you are) a concered parent, and a lover of great music. I think you have to follow your instincts as a parent, as well as know the new literature on child raising (or vocal pedagogy, for that matter). So, search your heart on this one, make a desicion, and help your child understand where you're coming from.
Just my opinion (and I protect my right to be wrong), David Grogan Longview, Texas
|
| |