Vocalist.org archive


From:  "Caio Rossi" <caiorossi@t...>
Date:  Sun Jan 27, 2002  3:54 pm
Subject:  Re: [vocalist] shiny happy people FOR mark!

I wa talking about singing. Other people started talking about Bocelli's
blindness. I could have interpreted that as if people meant to say blind
people can't have musical talent and depend on other people's pity to be
successful.


But I didn't make such a stupid interpretation because I can read, and
reading DOES NOT MEAN reacting to WORDS, as single words, ANY LINGUIST KNOWS
THAT, are meaningless.
And then Mark says he's not PC! hahaha

What I said of Bocelli's blindness and the 3 Tenors' appearance was
secondary, as my point was that they were successful regardless of whatever
reaction to their appearance, age, etc, etc. Only semi-illiterate people who
react to words because they can't understand sentences and paragraphs could
react negatively to what I said.

As I said, CONTINUOUS references to Bocelli's blindness and even to his
"latinhood", by Richard, to justify his success did not hurt anyone's
feelings, as they were against someone most people here disaprove of. Of
course, as my arguments demonstrated that explanation was weak and as it
means to many people that they can't belittle Bocelli's talent anymore by
using those artifices, it's better to nitpickly single out words from my
text so that they don't have to face the fact that people seem to prefer
Bocelli's "lack of talent" to the result they have achieved through years of
dedication.

I won't waste my time discussing with those egos anymore.

Caio



----- Original Message -----
From: drama_diva_au <drama_diva_au@y...>
To: <vocalist-temporary@yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Sunday, January 27, 2002 11:30 AM
Subject: Re: [vocalist] shiny happy people FOR mark!


>>>And my own grandmother is a big woman too....I don't call her a
fat grandma out of respect for her.
>
> Lea Ann<<<

First off, Lea Ann and Mark, thanks for having your say on this. I am
tired of this thread and appalled by the language used by some
members (one member?) to express themselves on this issue. As for the
above quote, Lea Ann, I think there is something further to this than
not saying it just out of respect. I would bet money that it wouldn't
even occur to you to refer to her (or anyone else for that matter) in
that manner no matter how she looked, because like many of us, it
just never enters your thinking to be that small minded, petty or
nasty about other human beings.

How about we get back to discussing singing, people, instead of being
vicious about those who have a career? It all begins to look like
jealousy, "sour grapes" and "Tall Poppy Syndrome" after a while and
it is not very pretty. Live and let live.

~Michelle













emusic.com