Vocalist.org archive


<
From:  sopran@a...
Date:  Mon Oct 22, 2001  4:34 pm
Subject:  Re: [vocalist] Re:soloist voice singing in the choir


In a message dated 10/22/01 2:16:08 PM, buzzcen@a... writes:

<< I'm beginning to come to the conclusion that young singers, who are
interested in developing their own voices, should not sing in choirs if the
director is one who tries to "dumb down" vibrant voices. Many times, these
directors ask for straight, breathy sounds that make girls especially sound
like castrated British school boys. >>

Randy,

Yes! And how about the choral directors who also want adult women to sound
like choirboys? (Vibrato BAD!!!!!) Something's wrong there, too!

Singers should be allowed to sing in a way that is comfortable and healthy
for them.
I won't work with anyone (other than my teacher, of course) who wants to
manipulate my voice.

Judy



emusic.com