So much has happened in this thread in such a short amount of time, it's hard picking which post(s) to respond to, so I'm going to make some general comments (from the perspective of a soprano).
I'm wondering if we're all using different terminology to mean the same things. I sing in a classical style, and when I sing the notes between about C4 and F4 (depending on context these can be a little higher or lower), I use head voice, but the resonance sounds like it's got a lot of chest mixed in, so much so that my teacher has had problems telling which register I'm using from the sound. I believe this is what is referred to as "mix" (chest mix by some, but I prefer head mix since I am using the muscles?? I use for head voice - please pardon my lack of knowledge of what the physical terminology is). If I'm careful I can transition through this from chest to head (or vice versa) without a break most of the time (I'm still getting used to the technique). I'm wondering if what some of us are referring to in this context as "head" or "head mix" others are referring to as "chest" or "chest mix" - it is hard to hear the difference, and based on some recent teaching experience, sometimes it's even hard for the singer to tell which register is being used.
Some people have been talking about speaking voice, and equating singing with that voice to singing in a chest register. I can assure you that I speak with all my voices - sometimes pure chest (when I'm trying to be heard in a noisy situation only), sometimes mixed chest (still in chest register but with a lighter sound), sometimes mixed head (head register but with a heavier sound like it's got chest mixed in - this is the one I use most often) and when I get really excited in pure head. I also sing in all of these registers, depending on the context. Why limit myself?
It is physically possible for me to carry chest up to an A4 (and a bit higher) but it is painful and strained sounding and definitely not something I would do for any reason. I can achieve a much more focussed, in tune and resonant sound by using my head voice (or a mix). Sometimes for stylistic reasons I will use chest for notes around C4 - E4 (even in opera it can be appropriate on occasion - listen to some of the great singers), but that is the exception rather than the rule. I can't speak for all other female singers, but this is my experience.
And lest anyone say that my lower notes are wimpy or wobbly because I do them in head/head mix, I can assure you that is not the case. Yesterday I performed in front of an audience of about 600. I was the only singer who wasn't miked, and I was the only one who was able to be heard on every note :o) (this is according to feedback I got from a number of audience members).
Jennifer
_______________________________________________________
|
| |