Vocalist.org archive


From:  sopran@a...
sopran@a...
Date:  Wed Aug 8, 2001  2:11 pm
Subject:  Re: [vocalist] Aria competition



In a message dated 8/8/01 12:24:06 AM, dalila@R... writes:

<< a prejudice
that I and a number of my spinto and dramatic-voiced friends have had to
butt up against over and over again. >>

Karen,

I know what you're talking about--and unfortunately, you don't even have to
be a spinto or dramatic to encounter it. I'm a big lyric, and I get that kind
of criticism frequently in CT, where I live--but not in NY. At home, I've had
conductors (baroque specialists), church choir directors and music club
members call me a dramatic soprano, which I most assuredly am not. But
compared to what they're used to hearing, I apparently sound like one. Go
figure!

Judy

emusic.com