Date sent: Thu, 16 Dec 1999 22:13:37 EST
Subject: Re: Help, nice teacher, poor technique
To: vocalist
Send reply to: VOCALIST <vocalist>

In a message dated 12/16/99 2:37:21 PM Central Standard Time, Jicasc-at-aol.com
writes:

<< After having!
!
studied with this teacher for a year, I am becoming concerned about whether
this method is good for me. I have signed up to "audition" with some other
teachers, with the idea that I would continue with this teacher as well. I'm
not sure if I should, though, but I really like this person, and this teacher
has been very kind to me. I feel torn between loyalty and doing what's best
for my voice and my education. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. >>

JC....it sounds as if you KNOW what you should do, which is find another
teacher. To continue with two different teachers is not only not a good idea
for you as a student, but is considered unethical. It is possible for you to
thank the teacher you are currently with for all of her help...get her a
lovely parting gift and write a lovely note, but make it clear that you are
moving on. The "warm ups" (or lack thereof) that you describe do not sound
even close to the type of vocalizing required to build a voice and improve
technique. YOU are the consumer...you must protect yourself & deserve to get
good instruction for your money. Believe me, good teachers understand (even
if they may be personally disappointed to lose a student). Teachers who are
very good have waiting lists & no problems filling vacancies...marginal
teachers sometimes hang on tenaciously to every student...even when they do
not know how to help the person improve. Good luck to you...NO GUILT...say
thank you (remember, you have paid this person for her time) and move on.
Regards, Barbara